본문 내용으로 건더뛰기
Advanced search
Research Monograph
Analysis on the Conflict of Interests between Financial Products Recommendation Service of Sales Channel and Retail Clients

December 31, 2015

  • Author OH. Yoonhae
  • Series No. Research Monograph 2015-06
  • Language Korean
PDF
Research Monograph
Analysis on the Conflict of Interests between Financial Products Recommendation Service of Sales Channel and Retail Clients

December 31, 2015

  • Author OH. Yoonhae
  • Series No. 2015-06
  • Language Korean
PDF
This study finds ways to resolve conflict of interests between financial products recommendation service of sales channel and retail clients in Korea. To that end, this study conducts an empirical analysis on mutual fund recommendation and fee, an on-line survey on the experience of mis-selling, and an survey of foreign cases on legal system of financial advisory.

After the global financial crisis, there is an increasing concern on consumers' financial loss from mis-selling and the asymmetric information and the complexity of financial products. Therefore, major countries, such as the UK and Australia, have made efforts to mitigate structural conflict of interests by reorganizing the legal system and regulation on the financial advisory service.

In Korean financial products market, number of complaints and disputes on mis-selling are consistently growing. Therefore, appropriate policies to mitigate the mis-selling are urgently required. In major countries with organized financial regulation and law, personal recommendation of a specific financial product is recognized as 'financial advice'. On the contrary, personal recommendation is regarded as a sales process in Korea, as 'financial advice' is not established as a legal concept for retail clients. Even though the financial authorities are considering an implementation of conflicts-free independent financial advisor, the recommendation service from current sales channel is not included as 'financial advice'.

This study confirms that sales channels' inclination to recommend relatively higher-commission products through mutual funds data, as well as Korean consumers’ perception and actual experience of conflict of interest through an online survey. It also suggests measures to promote the independent financial advice and upgrade the financial advice service by introducing recent regulatory reforms and laws on financial advice service in major countries.

Chapter 3 demonstrates that financial institutions tend to select mutual funds with higher sales fee in the recommendation lists on their web-pages. Even with regression analysis controlling other factors, fund sales fee and commission have statistically significant impact on the recommendation.

Chapter 4 carries out an online survey targeting 1,600 consumers who have ever bought insurances for investment or mutual funds within last 5 years. The result shows a considerable number of respondents experienced that sellers provided an insufficient explanation about the probability of principal loss, or they induced unsuitable higher-risk products. A regression result also shows that consumers with lower financial literacy are more likely to experience these mis-selling.

Consequently, below policies are required to protect financial consumers and invigorate independent financial advisors. First, a legal definition of financial advice should be established. Second, a structure of sales commission provided by current sales channel should be disclosed to consumers in detail. Third, financial authorities, even if not forced measures like in the UK, should suggest a balanced KPI (key performance indicators) to mitigate conflict of interest of financial advisors. Also, it is necessary to strengthen online sales platform for the pressure of competition.
 
Share to email
보안코드
CHECK Send to email address!
Office of Global Economy
Providing Economic Forecast and Macroeconomic Policy Direction, the Groundwork for a Brighter Future

The Department of Macroeconomics is conducting researches on the macro economy and macroeconomic policy, particularly focusing on suggesting the analysis of macroeconomic trends and current status of the economy at home and abroad, the economic forecast, and the policy direction of the macro economy. The Department is also in charge of establishing, sustaining and maintaining various econometric models, based on which it analyses policy effects and develops a long-term economic forecast.

Main Tasks
  • Economic trend analysis, short- and long-term forecast
  • Policy study on macroeconomic management
  • Basic structural analysis on macroeconomic areas
  • Maintenance of multi-sectoral dynamic macroeconomic model
Department of Macroeconomic Policy
  • LEE. Tae Suk

    Director, Division of Analysis and Evaluation

    82-044-550-4725
  • CHO, Byungkoo On leave

    Director and Vice President, Department of North Korean Economy

    82-044-550-4725
  • LEE, Jongkyu

    Fellow

    82-044-550-4725
  • WEE, Hyeseung Dispatched

    Research Associate

    82-044-550-4725
  • NAM, Jinwook On leave

    Specialist

    82-044-550-4725
  • KIM, Seulki

    Research Associate

    82-044-550-4725
  • CHUN, Eunkyung

    Research Associate

    82-044-550-4725
Contact email address

We reject unauthorized collection of email addresses posted on our website by using email address collecting programs or other technical devices. To access the email address, please type in the characters exactly as they appear in the box below.

Contact email address
Contact email address