Policy Study Evaluating the Effectiveness of Social Policies through a Policy Experiment System May 31, 2018

Series No. 2018-01
May 31, 2018
- Summary
-
This study proposes that a policy experiment system is introduced to examine the validity of new social polices. Such polices cannot be assessed with the existing Preliminary Feasibility Test and require a small-scale pilot program with an experimental design (typically, randomized controlled trial or RCT) to first be implemented. When the program ends, it is evaluated by the fiscal authorities to decide on whether to scale up the policy.
The policy experiment system presented in this study is applicable to social policies with the following characteristics: i) concrete objective; ii) measurable main outcome and realized in a short period of time and; iii) accessible control group. It is particularly useful when a policy is surrounded by skepticism and/or when budgetary needs are expected to increase in the near future. Accordingly, it can be concluded that the active labor market program is most suitable for the pilot application of the policy experiment system.
Chapter 1 briefly introduces the concept of the policy experiment system while Chapter 2 presents the implementation of the experiment through existing and new labor market programs. Prime examples are the Employment Success Package which was initiated in 2010 and the Youth Job Search Subsidy which is slated for 2019. Chapters 3 and 4 provide practical guides for researchers conducting the policy experiment and summarize the issues of conducting the experiment in the health and welfare field. Finally, Chapter 5 discusses the potential limitations of the system and draws on a conclusion.
- Contents
-
Preface
Executive Summary
Chapter 1 Introduction
Chapter 2 Policy Experiment Pilot Programs
Section 1 Overview
Section 2 Characteristics of Policies Suitable for Experiments
Section 3 Policy Experiment Scenarios: Employment Programs
Chapter 3 Guidelines for Conducting Policy Experiments
Section 1 Necessity of Random Assignment
Section 2 Methods of Random Assignment
Section 3 Data Collection
Section 4 Pre-Analysis Plan
Section 5 Research Ethics Review
Section 6 Analysis of Results
Section 7 Conclusion
Chapter 4 Policy Experiments in Health and Welfare
Section 1 Characteristics of Health and Welfare Programs
Section 2 Feasibility Assessment System for Health and Welfare Programs
Section 3 Considerations for Policy Experiments
Section 4 Implications for Policy Experiments
Chapter 5 Conclusion and Recommendations
References
ABSTRACT
If you want to know more in detail?
- Key related materials
We reject unauthorized collection of email addresses posted on our website by using email address collecting programs or other technical devices. To access the email address, please type in the characters exactly as they appear in the box below.
Please enter the security code to prevent unauthorized information collection.